By Rafe Calder
The Stanley Cup has been announced, bought, delivered, rebuilt and retired in pieces. A trophy that old does not stay one object. This piece sorts out which part is which, using two sources that agree on most things and disagree on a few.
The announcement
The Canadian Encyclopedia says Governor General Lord Stanley, Sir Frederick Arthur Stanley, announced the trophy on 18 March 1892. Its first name was the Dominion Hockey Challenge Cup, which “quickly became known as the Stanley Cup”. The Hockey Hall of Fame, the museum that holds the original, says he donated it in 1892 to go to “the championship hockey club of the Dominion of Canada”.
A small silver bowl
The encyclopedia describes what arrived: a small silver bowl, made in London, England, that reached Ottawa in early 1893. It was not yet a great object. It was a bowl.
Who got it first
Both main sources name the same winner: the Montreal Amateur Athletic Association. The Hall of Fame dates the award to 1893. The encyclopedia gives the season, 1892–93. These are the same event described two ways.
Two trustees, and what they did
The encyclopedia says two trustees were appointed by Stanley before he returned to England in 1893: Dr. John Sweetland, who served until his death in 1907, and Philip Dansken Ross, who served until his death in 1949. The Hall of Fame’s trustee table gives Ross from 1893 to 5 July 1949 and Sweetland from 1893 to 5 May 1907. The two accounts fit together. The Hall of Fame lists the line of trustees after them. We name no living trustee.
The challenge years
The encyclopedia describes how the Cup was first won and lost. From 1893 to 1914, teams could challenge the champion at any point in the season. From 1912, challenges were allowed only at the end of the champion’s regular season. In 1915 the champions of the NHA and the PCHA began contesting the Cup, which ended the challenge era.
The Hall of Fame has its own summary. Since 1910, when the National Hockey Association took possession of the Cup, it says, the trophy has been a symbol of professional hockey supremacy. Beginning in 1926, only NHL teams have competed for it.
Dates in order
- 18 March 1892 (encyclopedia): Stanley announces the trophy.
- Early 1893 (encyclopedia): the silver bowl arrives in Ottawa.
- 1893 (Hall of Fame): first award, to the Montreal Amateur Athletic Association.
- 1893 to 1914 (encyclopedia): challenge era.
- 1910 (Hall of Fame): the National Hockey Association takes possession.
- 1915 (encyclopedia): the NHA and PCHA champions begin contesting it.
- 1926 (both): the NHL takes control, according to the encyclopedia; only NHL teams compete, according to the Hall of Fame.
- 1993 (encyclopedia): winning players are allowed to keep the Cup for a day in summer.
Why it has bands
The Hall of Fame explains the growth. In its early life, it says, tiered rings were added to the bottom of the bowl from time to time. It calls the Cup the only professional sports trophy on which the name of every member of the winning team is inscribed. The result is a rule: when the bands fill, the older ones are retired to make room.
The encyclopedia gives the timetable. The first base ring was added by the Montreal Amateur Athletic Association in 1893 and used until 1903. Winners were engraved on the bowl from 1903 to 1909. The Montreal Wanderers were the first to engrave individual players’ names, in 1907, and engraving individual names became standard in 1924. A new base ring came in 1909 from the Ottawa Senators.
The Cup as it is built today
The Hall of Fame says the Cup consists of a bowl, three tiered bands, a collar and five barrel or uniform bands. It gives a height of 35.25 inches and a weight of 34.5 pounds. The encyclopedia describes the same parts with more detail: a replica of the original bowl, bands from 1893 to 1927, a shoulder collar listing winners from 1892–93 to 1991–92, and five barrel bands with room for 13 teams each. When the bottom band is full, the top band is retired to the Hockey Hall of Fame. It also says the Cup was redesigned in 1947 and 1957.
The retired bands and the original bowl are displayed together in Lord Stanley’s Vault in the Hall of Fame’s Esso Great Hall. In plain terms: the Cup you see lifted is not the bowl Stanley bought.
What kind of sources these are
A museum page, the national encyclopedia and one Wikipedia article for background. The museum is the keeper of the object, so its claims about the Cup’s history are partly its own.
Questions a buyer would ask
Is the Cup in a shop window a real Stanley Cup? The sources describe the original bowl and the retired bands in the vault, and a current Cup that is a rebuilt object. They do not describe commercial copies. Our reading: any smaller trophy sold as a gift is a replica of an idea, not of an object.
Does it matter which year a replica copies? The encyclopedia says the current Cup holds bands from 1893 to 1927 and a collar listing winners to 1991–92. Our reading: a copy that shows only one band tells you less than a copy that shows several.
What we left out
The purchase price, any sum for the Cup’s value, the names of living trustees and keepers, the stories about where the Cup has travelled, and any claim that Sephari stocks, sells or ships a trophy or replica.
Quick answers
Who gave the Stanley Cup? According to the Hockey Hall of Fame, Lord Stanley of Preston donated it in 1892 for “the championship hockey club of the Dominion of Canada”.
Who won it first? Both the Hockey Hall of Fame and the Canadian Encyclopedia name the Montreal Amateur Athletic Association, 1892–93.
Is the Cup we see today the original? The Canadian Encyclopedia says the original bowl is displayed in the Hall of Fame and the current Cup carries a replica of it. Retired bands are on show too.
Related on this site: banff-cave-and-basin-first-national-park, eatons-christmas-catalogue-wishing-book-history, canadian-block-heater-when-to-plug-in
Roam first. Shop later.