By Porter Lang
Start with the part that does the work. A hard shell, a cage, a strap.
Goalies in the old NHL stood in front of the net with no face protection at all. This piece follows how that changed, and it is a gear story as much as a hockey one. It reads three sources: Wikipedia’s article on Jacques Plante, Wikipedia’s article on the goaltender mask, and Britannica’s biography of Plante. They agree on the headline event and tangle a little over the details, so we show where.
The night of 1 November 1959
Wikipedia’s Plante article says Montreal played the New York Rangers on 1 November 1959. About three minutes in, a shot from Andy Bathgate broke Plante’s nose, and he went to the dressing room for stitches. Britannica says he needed 21 stitches in the face and was Montreal’s only goalie. When he came back he wore a crude homemade mask he had used in practice since 1956.
The coach, Toe Blake, was furious, according to Wikipedia, but he had no other goalie. Plante refused to play without it. Blake agreed on the condition that the mask come off once the cut healed. It did not. Blake stopped objecting as the team kept winning, and the unbeaten run reached 18 games.
One game without it
Wikipedia says that on 8 March 1960 Blake asked Plante to play without the mask against Detroit. Montreal lost 3-0, and the mask returned the next night. The mask article phrases this differently, saying he wore it for the rest of his career starting with a game on 9 March 1960. Those two dates line up, since 9 March is the next night.
Masks before 1959
The Wikipedia article on the goaltender mask lists earlier attempts:
- 1927: a Queen’s University netminder wore a metal fencing mask, mainly to protect her teeth.
- 1930: Clint Benedict wore a leather mask, which the article calls an American football nose-guard, to protect a broken nose. He stopped after he recovered.
- 1936: a goaltender from Japan wore a leather mask with a wire cage at the Winter Olympics.
Our reading: the 1959 mask was not the first. It was the first to stay. The Plante article says he is credited with making the mask everyday equipment, and Britannica says nearly all later goaltenders wore face masks following his example.
Materials, in order of arrival
The mask article gives the sequence. First came a fibreglass shell contoured to the face. Later cage-style masks used carbon fibre, or a fibreglass and Kevlar mix. A helmet-and-cage combination was popularized in the 1970s by a single international goaltender, whom we leave out. A fibreglass shell with a wire cage, the combo mask, was developed in the late 1970s and is now the most common type. The article calls it safer than the helmet-cage style. It does not say what test showed that.
Fibreglass is not magic. Wikipedia’s Plante article says that in the 1969-70 playoffs against Boston a deflected shot hit Plante in the forehead and broke his fibreglass mask. He said the mask saved his life. Our reading: that is a useful line for a buyer of any protective gear. A mask is rated against a certain hit, not every hit.
Dates in order
- 1927: fencing mask at Queen’s University.
- 1930: leather mask worn by Benedict.
- 1936: caged leather mask at the Olympics.
- 1956: Plante’s homemade mask in practice.
- 1 November 1959: the game with the Rangers.
- 8 and 9 March 1960: the mask comes off for one game, then goes back on.
- 1969-70: fibreglass mask cracks in the playoffs.
- 1974: the last NHL game played without a mask, according to the mask article.
Artwork on the shell
The mask article says modern goaltenders often decorate masks with custom designs and sometimes carry their themes to new teams. It also describes a Bruins goaltender’s “stitch mask”, which began as a joke by the team trainer and grew into one of hockey’s best-known designs. That goaltender went on to set an NHL record of 32 straight wins in 1971-72, according to the article.
Side by side
| Point | Plante article | Mask article | Britannica |
|---|---|---|---|
| First mask game | 1 Nov 1959 vs Rangers | 1 Nov 1959 (Bathgate shot) | 1959 game |
| Injury | nose broken, stitches | struck in the face | 21 stitches |
| Mask in practice | since 1956 | not mentioned | not mentioned |
| Return to mask | next night | 9 March 1960 | not given |
Questions a buyer would ask
Is a cage mask safer than a fibreglass shell? The mask article calls the combo mask safer than the helmet-cage style. It gives no figures.
Are there rules for the bars? The article says cats-eye bars are banned in Hockey Canada minor hockey unless extra bars reduce the openings. Check current league rules for anything more.
What kind of sources these are
Two user-edited encyclopedia pages and one national reference work. We did not reach the Hockey Hall of Fame or Hockey Canada pages, so certification marks and current rules are not covered.
What we left out
The player’s life away from the rink, and any piece of safety advice that rests on a sum or a standard we could not read.
Quick answers
Who made the goalie mask normal in the NHL? Wikipedia credits Jacques Plante, who wore one after a shot broke his nose on 1 November 1959.
Was Plante the first to wear a mask? No. Wikipedia lists earlier masks in 1927, 1930 and 1936.
When did the last NHL goalie play without a mask? Wikipedia’s mask article gives 1974.
Related on this site: montreal-underground-city-reso-winter, mcintosh-apple-dundela-ontario-national-apple, northern-lights-yellowknife-aurora-colours
Roam first. Shop later.